Skip to content

No Service to Learning: “Service-Learning” Reappraised

Summer 2008

Mixing community service with college students’ learning is a bad idea. When service-learning was promoted in a newspaper op-ed by Dr. Robert L. Caret,1 the president of Towson University (where I have taught for over two decades), I responded skeptically.2 Dr. Caret’s follow-up letter suggested that I misunderstood service-learning.3

I argued that wrapping a veneer of learning over community service conceals the promotion of a particular social agenda, that it wastes students’ valuable time and other resources, and that its learning goal actually weakens students’ respect for the processes of social interaction that is conveyed by a good liberal education.

Like many op-eds, mine was written quickly, but I think a closer look4 reveals no substantive problem: service-learning attempts to promote a communitarian, anti-individualistic social agenda, and the attempt and agenda are educationally harmful.5

What

Continue Reading

Get access to this article, plus the entire archive, by subscribing.

Subscribe